gatekeeping is good

It is unproductive when the gatekeeper creates policies that generate unnecessary work. The things you listed as good forms of gatekeeping don't require someone to prove they belong. A gatekeeping approach to gender-affirming care is founded on the idea that hormonal therapy may be harmful to patients--either directly, through the biological and chemical consequences of such treatment, or because of the 'social risks', or the fear that patients … The irony. /r/gatekeeping is a subreddit for screenshots and stories of gatekeepers in the wild. The very concept of a gatekeeper is unquestionably a good thing. It’s good to see people recognizing how absurd *gatekeeping* hobbies is. Gatekeeping Works of literature and the standards we use to judge them can never actually be timeless or universal in the casual sense in which we often use these words. Welcome to Beer is for Everyone and thanks for being here. That wasn't gatekeeping. Anonymous 03/13/21(Sat)01:27:55 No. hide. Gatekeeping is the term used to describe the role of primary care physicians or general practitioners (GPs) in authorising access to specialty care, hospital care, and diagnostic tests.1 Gatekeeping has crucial influences on service utilisation, health outcomes, healthcare costs, and patient satisfaction. However, one study reported unfavourable outcomes for patients with cancer under gatekeeping, and some concerns were raised about the accuracy of diagnoses made by gatekeepers. 7 7. comments. Treat the gatekeeper as an extension of the decision maker. Maybe some day we can return to tweeting about the simple mundanities of life. There is never cases where its not, I don't care how much of a fan you are, you have no right to gatekeep people out of the franchise. Gatekeeping by physicians has been both advocated and contested as a way to make health care choices at the level of the individual. Although informed consent models for prescribing hormone replacement therapy are becoming increasingly prevalent, many physicians continue to require an assessment and referral letter from a mental health professional prior to prescription. For Pokemon Sword on the Nintendo Switch, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Gatekeeping is not a bad thing: Good or bad?" Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Gatekeeping is all about drawing a line around roles that are perceived to be comparatively high value, and in tech, there are two primary dimensions along which this value is expressed. In several countries, physicians have been assigned a gatekeeper role for secondary health care. 2.9k comments. Gatekeeping is an essential tool in diverting children from unnecessary initial entry into alternative care, and reducing the numbers of children entering institutions. Thanks for downvoting out of disagreement :) You must really get how this subreddit works, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the unpopularopinion community. Embrace, Extend, Extinguish The road to hell is paved with good intentions. Mine was different than theirs, so they freaked and called me close-minded. The NHS is at one extreme in terms of gatekeeping in health systems. In addition, avoid using trickery or outright deception to get past a gatekeeper. Let’s try to understand it by looking at the pros. One objective of a parent is to allow “in” people who are good influences in the child’s life and keep “out” people who might be harmful. The pros and cons surrounding the system of gatekeeping really question its effectiveness. ---If you would consider supporting this boomer's endeavours, here's all the usual e-begging and self-shilling 'content creator' links! Instead, it stops people who have proved they can't be mature in some way. On the other hand, no system is perfect, if the good can outweigh the bad, the gatekeeper system can be helpful in reducing health care cost and organize how patients receive care. Most managers believe a good gatekeeper is worth their weight in gold. 102226674. Everyone has a limit with what they call and don't call music. Gatekeeping is good.... /s. Well, not necessarily. Tldr, gatekeeping is good. Gatekeeping can have a hugely damaging effect on someone who is just coming to terms with a diagnosis, or who is unsure about whether they need to seek help. Whole it's usually portrayed to be a negative thing by mainstream media, it does keep the shitter from polluting a prestigious community otherwise Pic related is good gatekeeping >> Anonymous 03/11/21(Thu)04:42:03 No. 4. Gatekeeping is good.... /s. Archived. It’s good to see people recognizing how absurd *gatekeeping* hobbies is. 547652676 >>547652323 >prestigious community Uh, anon, these are … The main character is stuck in an abusive marriage which the showrunners seem to be oblivious to, meanwhile his abuser (originally quite a decent character, played by a talented actress) has been written into a mary sue, essentially taking over the show and sidelining the original lead. In geek, nerd, and niche culture, “gatekeeping” refers to fans within a community (usually older, more experienced fans) imposing standards upon others (usually … Gatekeeping is always bad, and you're a dick if you do it It's not always back. When someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity. Any group with insufficient gatekeeping will end up at the mercy of toxic individuals. Conservation starts with falling in love with America’s public lands. Additionally, Rav points out that this type of gatekeeping ignores the fact that we are all susceptible to mental health issues, which may not always be a consistent experience. Connie's winning strategies sent right to your inbox each month! And yet judgments about what is good or bad, worthy of attention, "literary" or not aren't entirely socially determined. /r/gatekeeping is a subreddit for screenshots and stories of gatekeepers in the wild. Anyone who isn't calling to complain or to buy something, but instead wants something for themselves, such as a salesperson, is denied access. And I do think it's silly to say "you're not a real man if you....." Good gate keeping. Any gatekeeping beyond the minimum amount necessary to serve this vital function is harmful. Take any feedback and advice with a grain of salt, everyone’s opinion about your edit will be subjective. Gatekeeping is the term used to describe the action of determining who is and isn’t allowed “entry” into a group of people. It is a surefire way to end a business relationship before it starts. Gatekeeping is always bad, and you're a dick if you do it Gatekeeping is usually bad, but there are cases where it is not. The first is about having control over technical decisions. Gatekeeping literature is much more than wanting people not to read the books you like. The dependency on the supervisor might not be a good way to drive accountability. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Any group with excessive gatekeeping will become toxic. >> Anonymous 03/25/21(Thu)08:41:14 No. It gives senior management the opportunity to hear first hand what’s going on in their business. It can be as important as ensuring only scientists get to handle unstable chemicals, to something as innocuous as making sure the “teachers only” lounge stays teachers only. Gatekeeping doesn’t have to be toxic: Keeping children out of adult entertainment venues is certainly an example of gatekeeping, but it’s a damned good idea in that context. Though some attempted to make a case for gatekeeping nerdom from the normies, most people argued that letting others enjoy things is fine and good. The gatekeeper screens calls and visitors, typically deflecting ones they believe are unimportant. Otaku Lifestyle. In a similar vein, content moderation is a good thing, but necessarily involves some gatekeeping behaviors. Gatekeeping is when someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity. It’s good for morale when staff feel they are being listened to and have a relationship with their senior management team. Gatekeeping is when someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights … Press J to jump to the feed. Got a burning unpopular opinion you want to share? Gatekeeping is a process by which information is filtered to the public by the media. If a game is good, it's good, I don't care if plebs get to be aware of its existence >> Anonymous 03/25/21(Thu)08:42:57 No. Although informed consent models for prescribing hormone replacement therapy are becoming increasingly prevalent, many physicians continue to require an assessment and referral letter from a mental health professional prior to prescription. Gatekeeping thus applies to childcare and the fact that a vital role of parents is to supervise others’ access to their children. That was far from the truth, though. In a similar vein, content moderation is a good thing, but necessarily involves some gatekeeping behaviors. Cultural Gatekeeping: Preference, Prejudice, and Power Why marginalized groups continue to need dedicated spaces, in the beer world and beyond by Ruvani de Silva . Posted by 2 years ago. Many ethicists oppose this assignment for several reasons, concentrating on the harm the intrusion of societal arguments would inflict on doctor-patient relations. "Gatekeeping," as it is used on this web site, is the process of referring children and families to appropriate services or care arrangements with the aim of limiting the number of inappropriate placements. This is what fags like them do with everything >gatekeeping … Cultural infiltrator terrorists do the same thing. Gatekeeping is an essential tool in diverting children from unnecessary initial entry into alternative care, and reducing the numbers of children entering institutions. Log In Sign Up. Anonymous 03/13/21(Sat)01:22:44 No. Gatekeeping was never as simple as “this is good” and “that is bad,” but the recent wave of sexual assault and harassment scandals revealed some hidden gears in the process. 102226754. Questioning someone’s authenticity when it comes to something that takes a lot of hard work and study isn’t gatekeeping. report. Some people are extreme with it and some aren't, but we need it. Or is it about scheduling, prioritising, good planning and effective time management? Gatekeeping and its rationalities—an example. Posted by 1 year ago. Not to cast judgment on anyone who engages in such behaviour, as I do sympathize with the view of wanting to keep anime niche and as far away from the mainstream as possible. After all, you believe in diversity of thought! There Are Better Ways To Protect Public Lands from Overuse. In times like these, one has to wonder what things might have been like had the fans who only watched the show to see two attractive people make out been slapped down before things got out of hand. 58.1k. /r/gatekeeping is a subreddit for screenshots and stories of gatekeepers in the wild. Capcom simply followed sales numbers and customer input. Good gate keeping. It’s natural to want to stay in control of your child’s care, but maternal gatekeeping can lead to a growing conflict between you and your partner, as well as mom burnout—after all, if you’re always watching over your child, even when it’s someone else’s turn to care for him, you’re going to feel exhausted and depleted by the end of the day. It’s a counterintuitive point, but it makes sense when explained fully. After Sometimes gatekeeping is a good thing. The Devil May Cry fandom did it to people who bought DmC and now look: We got DMC5. Poor gatekeeping undermines good corporate governance, which results in social-wealth-destroying suboptimal corporate decision making. A good gatekeeping policy is one that balances clinical needs, patient choice, and system constraints. The key aspect is to relentlessly harass and bully those that misinterpret the books you like, and to make fun of them for being shallow and pretentious. Anonymous 03/11/21(Thu)04:42:03 No. When those people questioned this teen, others in the comments were quick to cry out that they were gatekeeping Reiki. Gatekeeping is when someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity. User account menu. All Rights Reserved, Leverage Your Resources to Optimize Results, Case: Harmonization Strategy and Operational Alignment, Case: Design of Corporate Performance Measures, eBook: Doing More with Less Through Operational Excellence, eBook: Enhance Performance Through Process Improvement. 102226754 >>102225402 All the people against gatekeeping are just gatekeeping against gatekeepers. save. Bureaucracy—as the gatekeeper holds the liberty to exercise authority, the risk of abusing that authority for personal gain turns into bureaucracy. I know a lot of people hate being told what makes someone a "real" fan, but sometimes, it can be necessary. To me, what I often see is that everyone is a "gatekeeper" in some way. As with many things in life, toxicity is determined by the dose. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Physicians are increasingly confronted with the consequences of allocation policies. Capcom simply followed sales numbers and customer input. Gatekeeping is the activity of controlling or limiting access to something, and in its most general form, gatekeeping is common in almost every aspect of daily life. Not to cast judgment on anyone who engages in such behaviour, as I do sympathize with the view of wanting to keep anime niche and as far away from the mainstream as possible. Their "shippers" have even gone a step further to start formulating rumours about the two actors having an affair in real life, despite one being married. Finding the right balance is not easy. February 16, 2019. Much of the resulting commentary considers it in wider context, including abuse of power that might not be sexual in nature, but nevertheless encumbers women and people of color in their careers. Apart from the hand wringing, gatekeeping and purity tests coming from certain (very vocal) corners of the internet, I would argue that social media is making public land users more diverse. You let them in because you want to be welcoming and inclusive. For example, in your pic, you can just let enter the people that want to play the game and not change it, and if they want to change it and not accept the rules tell them to fuck off. - Page 4. gatekeeping is morally unsound and factually suspect; that there are condi- tions under which rationing might be morally justifiable, but they are not met by current plans, and … So what is gatekeeping all about? This thread is archived. Gatekeeping has known as the most easily reached theories as well as the most continuing research in mass communication. Drawing on personal and communal experience, the author argues that assessment and referral requirements are dehumanising and unethical, … Anonymous 03/25/21(Thu)08:41:14 No. I know a lot of people hate being told what makes someone a "real" fan, but sometimes, it can be necessary. For example, if you take a look at the CW show Arrow ( r/arrow) You'll see what happens when someone in charge of a product a fandom is based around starts catering towards a... certain type of fan. Your email address will not be published. Time Management So is gatekeeping about blocking access and stopping the communication flow as some suggest? 547652676. Log In Sign Up. 549446543. We've got a bunch of cringey and eye-roll inducing examples of groundless gatekeeping thanks to all the avid screenshotters out there. There are two different strands to tease out there. Gatekeeping was associated with better quality of care and appropriate referral for further hospital visits and investigation. One morning, Mr Jansen walks into the office with some difficulty, right hand against his back, painful grin. User account menu. How to Capture Operations Data that You Can Leverage. The Devil May Cry fandom did it to people who bought DmC and now look: We got DMC5. >> 3 2 23. The good thing about gatekeeping is that you can open the gate. Sometimes, gatekeeping can be a good thing. After all, you shouldn’t trust everything that you hear without a little scrutiny. I was blasted on Reddit for calling electronic music "not real music" and cue the "DOH, REEEEEEEEEE, GATEKEEPING BLAH BLAH" bullshit. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Gatekeeping. Gatekeeping tends to be when people say others aren't a "true fan" if they don't do xyz, or say that certain people shouldn't be allowed based on something arbitrary. In contrast, Vedsted and Olesen (2011) highlight potential adverse effects of gatekeeping on health care quality and health outcomes. Typically, you’ll see gatekeeping behaviors being used against newer fans of the medium who are not displaying the proper knowledge that would be acceptable if … Whenever people talk about gatekeeping, they usually talk about it in a negative way. Gatekeeping is defined as “the activity of controlling, and usually limiting, general access to something,” and in the case of the internet and especially fandoms, it is a method of determining who is and is not a real fan of a certain medium. Open Communication In any business open communication is important. Gatekeeping is when someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or … Press J to jump to the feed. Gatekeeping can take many forms, but generally refers to the act of limiting a person’s access to something, be it a community, a label or even a diagnosis, because they don’t live up to certain standards set by those already initiated. Gatekeeping is a good thing >> Anonymous 03/13/21(Sat)01:22:44 No. "Gatekeeping, basically, is the term you use for keeping people out of the circle as it gets smaller," explains Jukeyz. On a community level, the most dangerous mentality to internalize is one that wholeheartedly vilifies “gatekeeping.”. Since then I’ve had good and mediocre experiences with hiring editors and my friends have as well. hide . Close. 86% Upvoted. Gatekeeping is frowned upon, so I don't recommend doing it. Policy makers may worry that relaxing gatekeeping will result in a flood of patients knocking on specialists’ doors. It's also a really stupid thing to do. So does this mean gatekeeping is good, then? save. share. We've collected some tweets from the gatekeeping anime discourse to paint a picture of the toxicity of Twitter for you. Gatekeeping goes beyond telling people what they should and shouldn’t be using. Gatekeeping is when someone takes it upon themselves to decide who does or does not have access or rights to a community or identity. Is gatekeeping a good thing? People feel inspired to go see and be a part of outdoor spaces they may have never entered otherwise—and that’s a good thing. Moreover, gatekeeping includes many types such as venture capital firms, exhibition and museum curators, journal and magazine editorial committees, and others. 1 million people could read whatever book this is, and that would be totally fine with me, as long as they get made fun of online when they misunderstand it.

Bernar Venet Versailles, Visa Russie Covid, L'invention De Hugo Cabret Film, Parole Célèbre De Faustin Soulouque, War All Day Music, Limer Mots Fléchés, Musée Guggenheim New York Visite Virtuelle, Notice Compteur électronique Edf, Drapeau Bleu Avec étoile Blanche,